How to Tell If an eBay Seller Is Legit

In the vast universe of online shopping, eBay stands as one of the longest-standing and most popular platforms.

But, like any online marketplace, not every seller is reputable. While most transactions on eBay are smooth, understanding how to tell if an eBay seller is legit is crucial for a secure and successful shopping experience.

Understanding eBay’s Safety Measures

Before diving into ways to evaluate sellers, it’s beneficial to comprehend eBay’s intrinsic safety measures.

Feedback System

One of eBay’s most potent tools is its feedback system. Every buyer gets the chance to leave feedback after a transaction.

Over time, a seller accumulates these ratings, providing a numerical score and percentage of positive feedback.

  • Positive Feedback Percentage: Ideally, aim for sellers with 98% or higher positive feedback. But, remember, everyone can have an off day or encounter a tricky customer.
  • Number of Feedbacks: A seller with 1,000 feedbacks and a 99% positive rating is generally more reliable than one with 10 feedbacks at 100%.

eBay Money Back Guarantee

This is a policy eBay stands by, ensuring that if an item doesn’t arrive or isn’t as described, the buyer can receive a refund.

Seller Protections

eBay provides various tools and protections for sellers, ensuring they operate in a transparent manner. Understanding these can give buyers peace of mind too.

How to Tell If an eBay Seller Is Legit?

Ensuring you’re dealing with a reputable seller is paramount. Here are steps to make an informed decision:

Examine the Feedback Profile

Apart from looking at the overall score:

  • Check out recent feedback, both positive and negative.
  • Read comments left by other buyers.

Review the Listing in Detail

A legitimate seller:

  • Provides clear, high-quality photos of the actual item (not stock photos).
  • Offers a detailed description, covering item condition, specifications, and any defects.
  • Answers questions transparently and promptly.

Communication is Key

Don’t hesitate to contact the seller:

  • Ask about the item’s history or request additional photos.
  • Gauge their response time and professionalism.

Spotting Red Flags

Awareness of potential red flags can protect you from scams:

Too Good to Be True Pricing

While everyone loves a good deal, if a price seems too good to be true, it might just be. Compare the item’s price with other listings on eBay and other platforms.

Vague Listings

A legit seller will ensure their listing is transparent and informative. Avoid listings with:

  • Unclear or vague item descriptions.
  • A lack of authentic photos.

New Accounts Selling High-Value Items

While new sellers need to start somewhere, be cautious if a new account is selling high-priced items. They might be legitimate, but it’s worth extra diligence.

Utilizing Third-Party Tools

There are external tools and websites that analyze eBay seller data:

  • WatchCount: This tool lets you see what a seller’s most popular listings are, providing insights into their selling trends.
  • eBay Feedback Checker: It parses negative feedback, so you can see patterns in complaints.

Remember, while tools can assist, they’re supplementary to the personal diligence detailed above.


Online shopping on platforms like eBay can be a rewarding experience. Knowing how to tell if an eBay seller is legit is essential for both peace of mind and safeguarding your purchases.

By understanding eBay’s safety measures, meticulously analyzing feedback, staying aware of red flags, and leveraging third-party tools, you’ll position yourself for a smooth eBay buying journey.

Photo of author

Connect: Insta



Edward brings years of experience in a variety of different fields including online marketing & No-code app development, and he's been investing in stocks and cryptocurrency since 2016. Outside of work you'll usually find him watching movies at the local cinema or playing games in the Apple Arcade.

Read more from Edward


Apps UK
International House
12 Constance Street
London, E16 2DQ